Assumptions are a common cause of mistakes. In any workplace, we often make the best decision that we can at a given moment. But when a lack of knowledge is replaced with assumptions… that decision might turn out to be a bad one.
So it’s important to recognize when we know something to be true and when we’re making an assumption.
Case in point, this story:
ESPN’s Michael Kay Profusely Apologizes For ‘Huge Mistake’ In Scoop On NFL Coach
In September 2023, Kay apologized for “reporting” that New York Giants head coach Brian Daboll threw a party the night before they got blown out by the Dallas Cowboys 40-0 in their NFL home opener.
That sounds awful, right?
“I have it on good authority that Brian Daboll had a huge party at his house on Saturday night. This is true,” Kay said. “You’re not throwing a big party if you’re about to get your butt kicked by the Cowboys.”
The word “party” can lead us to fill in details that nobody has verified.
Oops.
The missing context changed the story.
Daboll threw a daytime birthday party for his six-year-old son.
Kay admitted this was a “huge mistake” and I admire his willingness to admit the obvious mistake. He assumed the worst and it turned out not to be true.
“I need to make a heartfelt apology to Brian Daboll,” said Kay. He continued, “I should have done more work. I’m a complete ass for doing this, and I feel sorry for any pain I might have caused that family by insinuating anything. But I found out later it was a party for his 6-year-old, it was a birthday party.”
“I should have dug deeper,” Kay went on, “and I didn’t think it was going to be a big thing, but it became sort of a big thing last night, and I want to cut it off at the legs and say that is on me, and I was irresponsible because I didn’t check it out further and I apologize to anybody that was impacted by my flippant remark about a party at his house.”
“I just feel like a complete idiot,” he added.
It helps to apologize after making a mistake. Kay took ownership of his assumption and his mistake.
That doesn’t change what happened, but it’s better than denying the mistake or doubling down on it.
Separate what you know from what you assume
Before criticizing a colleague, I would ask: What did I observe? What did somebody tell me? What am I adding to the story? Those are different kinds of information. A confident interpretation is still an interpretation.
In this case, asking what kind of party it was would have changed the discussion. At work, the missing question might be why a deadline slipped or what prevented somebody from following a process. Checking an assumption gives us a chance to learn before we make the situation worse.
An apology needs a next step
I appreciate Kay taking responsibility. Calling yourself an idiot, however, does not explain how you will avoid the next mistake. A more useful response names the error, corrects the information for the people who heard it, and changes the way the next claim gets checked.
That is also a leadership practice. Make it easy for people to question your conclusion, including after you have stated it confidently. Thank the person who supplies the missing context. Then show what changed. As with fact-checking in journalism, the goal is a more reliable process, not simply a stronger warning to be careful.
Bring a useful conversation to your team
Start with a free preview of The Mistakes That Make Us. See how the book approaches learning, accountability, and improvement before deciding whether it is right for you.
Prefer to listen? Choose a My Favorite Mistake episode to discuss with your team. To explore these ideas together, bring Mark to your organization or event.


