Bad assumptions can turn a reasonable-looking decision into a mistake. The challenge is noticing what we are taking for granted before we commit more time, money, or trust to a plan.
In my My Favorite Mistake conversations, guests often describe decisions that made sense to them at the time. Looking back helps us see the gap between what they knew and what they assumed. The stories below come from material I developed for The Mistakes That Make Us that did not make the final book.
Why Do We Make Mistakes?
Why do we make mistakes? Because we’re human.
OK, end of story. Thanks for reading.
Slips, or execution mistakes, are easier to explain, as they can be caused by all sorts of human fallibilities, such as fatigue, distraction, or confusing work processes. Even at our best, we’re going to make mistakes.
Planning mistakes are based on decisions we make — the best we can do at a certain time.
Guests have shared their My Favorite Mistake stories centered around a decision (or a series of decisions) that seemed like the right decision at the time. Once we see a mistake, it might be caused by:
- Bad assumptions
- Bad information
- Incomplete information
- Not listening to others
- Listening to the wrong people
- Not listening to yourself
- Expecting that past performance will guarantee future results
We might base a decision on bad information. But, even if we have all the needed information, our cognitive biases might still trip us up — there we go again, being human.
Bad Assumptions
Many of my guests shared stories where the root of the mistake was a bad assumption. An assumption often replaces knowledge or facts and can be a dangerous substitute. We sometimes have to work from assumptions, but it’s helpful to distinguish what we know from what we are assuming. We’re better off stating our assumptions as such so that we can test (and prove or possibly disprove) the assumption(s), and perhaps prevent a mistake (or making a small mistake instead of a large one).
Leslie Tayne: questioning the need for a partner
Leslie Tayne is an award-winning financial attorney and author of Life and Debt. Her favorite mistake was the assumption she made when starting her first law firm over 20 years ago. Leslie approached a male classmate and asked him to partner with her for the sole reason (her assumption) that she needed a man because the legal industry was male-dominated.
She recognized her mistake within two months as she learned they didn’t share the same vision and values. Leslie moved quickly to dissolve the partnership and went out on her own as a woman, learning that other factors mattered more than gender — and she was indeed successful without a male partner.
It wasn’t an overnight decision; it might have been a mistake to act too rashly, but it certainly would have been a mistake to keep that relationship going out of fear of admitting a mistake.
Gene Rice: checking the requirements before committing
In our conversation, Gene Rice described his work as chairman and co-founder of Rice Cohen International and has been recognized as one of the top executive search professionals in the world through his 30 years in the field. Young Gene was the manager, in the late 1970s, of the top music club on Long Island, booking acts including The Ramones, Bo Diddley, and Billy Joel. After butting heads with the owner, Gene decided to go out on his own to open a competing club. This decision was full of bad assumptions, as Gene quickly learned.
- He assumed he could open a club quickly but learned it would take a year to get the state liquor license.
- He assumed that buying one of the four establishments with a “cabaret” license for live music meant he could replace occasional organ music in an “old man bar” with punk rock bands in the adjoining event space. He learned the community would push back hard on that plan.
Gene describes that club as his “greatest failure,” saying, “It could have destroyed me, but I learned so much from that mistake. I never ever took success for granted again. Every business decision I made was a very calculated decision,” including the way he started his search firm in a far less impulsive way. Gene was leaving a six-figure corporate job, so he took care to leave on good terms, making a deal with his CEO that his new firm would serve their recruitment needs.
When mentoring younger executives, Gene sees them often struggling to bounce back the first time they experience failure. He teaches them, “Failure is part of life, right? You have to take ownership of it. You can’t blame someone else.”
“You have to take ownership for the mistakes you made. You have to identify and write down what you’re going to do differently the next time. How are you going to move forward? I think real failure is making the same mistake twice. If you can fail, but you can now look at it with a different set of eyes and more information, then it can be a learning experience, and it can propel you in life. That failure I shared with you about the bar, it propelled me in my career going forward.”
Ellen Patnaude: listening before assuming credibility
Ellen Patnaude is a business communication coach who describes herself as a “truth teller, people-ing guru, and tough cookie.” Knowing her since high school, it’s not a mistake to use those descriptors, although a less censored version of herself says she’s “a general bad ass” and it might be a mistake to use that phrase in certain settings.
Ellen found herself in a new setting, back in 1998, as a “young white girl” walking into a Black church in Chicago. Wanting to build some credibility, Ellen shared an experience from a similar community meeting back in her hometown of Detroit. After being asked, “What the hell does that experience have to do with us in Chicago?” Ellen made the mistake of doubling down, arguing instead of apologizing. The pushback became more pointed, and she felt like she had been slapped in the face.
She assumed her past experiences would give her a seat at this new table, but she was mistaken. It was “a very embarrassing moment, and it was an incredibly important lesson.” As a community organizer, Ellen learned to stop making assumptions and to start listening more.
Ellen worked productively in Chicago for two years after apologizing, “eating some humble pie,” and getting over herself. The community leader who had rejected Ellen’s assumption later told her, “We’re here because we all believe in the same thing. So take the lump and learn the lesson and do better. We expect you to do better. We didn’t hire you to behave like that.” She learned, did better, and moved forward.
Ellen also noticed a broader pattern of getting in trouble as the result of a bad assumption. It was a pattern she noticed among professionals she later coached in different workplaces, which led her to write the book I Thought You Knew…: Confessions of a Chronic Assumer (and How You Can Stop Guessing Your Way Through Important Interactions).
Scott O’Neil: checking how a plan will reach customers
Scott O’Neil was the CEO of Harris Blitzer Sports and Entertainment, the company that owns the New Jersey Devils of the NHL and the Philadelphia 76ers of the NBA. In a previous role, he worked for the NBA league office and volunteered to take a role with the fledging women’s league, the WNBA.
Having daughters who loved the game, he assumed that the way to fill seats at WNBA games was to attract teenage girls, and he further assumed that cross-promotions with the “boy band” NSYNC would accomplish that. It helped that his friend managed the group, and he could make that happen. But it turned out to be a mistake, a flop.
Scott’s hypotheses about higher ticket sales didn’t pan out. In fact, ticket sales dropped. Why did it fail? Scott learned that the promotional materials never got out of the distribution centers in four key markets.
“Being young and knowing everything in the world,” Scott reacted to the failure by blaming others for “not getting it” and for not doing enough to promote the partnership. An executive challenged him, “What role did you play?” and pointed out that Scott hadn’t done enough to build relationships with others within the WNBA and NBA. He hadn’t focused on the relationships and the operations that would have made sure the promotional materials weren’t just stuck in boxes.
Scott recalls, “That conversation with Jeff transformed the trajectory of my experience at the NBA because I wouldn’t have stayed. They probably wouldn’t have wanted me to stay.” Scott stayed for eight years and built relationships that catapulted him to new heights.
“You trip, you fall, you fail, you learn. That has to be the formula for life. That notion of intellectual curiosity is something I’ve learned from every great leader I’ve ever been around. They’re all learning all the time.” – Scott O’Neil
How to check assumptions before a decision
Try writing down three things: what you know, what you assume, and what you still need to learn. For the assumption that matters most, ask what evidence would change your mind. Then choose a small, safe way to get that evidence before expanding the commitment.
Who sees the work differently? Invite that person to challenge the plan. As the Dwayne Rudd story illustrates, acting on an assumption before checking what actually happened can create a second problem.
After a mistake, ask what made the decision seem reasonable at the time. That question can reveal missing information or a weak process. It also helps us look at our own contribution instead of jumping to blame. Learning needs to lead to a change we can test.
Bring a useful conversation to your team
Start with a free preview of The Mistakes That Make Us. See how the book approaches learning, accountability, and improvement before deciding whether it is right for you.
Prefer to listen? Choose a My Favorite Mistake episode to discuss with your team. To explore these ideas together, bring Mark to your organization or event.


