Choosing a podcast name involves a tradeoff: a name can capture the idea well and still be difficult for a new listener to find. That was the concern I explored when I wrote this post in January 2024 about My Favorite Mistake.
Creating the podcast wasn’t the mistake I was questioning. I liked the name. It was fitting and pithy. But sharing a title with a well-known Sheryl Crow song created a discovery problem I had not fully considered.
A memorable name can have unexpected competition
At the time, searching for “My Favorite Mistake” in an app with music and podcasts brought up many versions of Crow’s song before my show. Those were my observations then, not a promise about what you will see in search results today.
I wondered whether “My Favorite Business Mistake” or “Our Favorite Mistakes” would have been a better choice. But a distinctive phrase only solves part of the problem. Someone who has never heard of the show might not know to search for it.
That led me to a different question: what would a person search for if they wanted the kinds of conversations I was recording? Phrases such as “business mistakes” or “learning from mistakes” described the subject more directly. My searches at the time gave me reasons to question whether the name was as bad a choice as I initially feared.
An imperfect outcome does not prove a bad decision
We choose a path believing it makes sense with the information we have. Some consequences become visible only after we have started. That does not mean every disappointing result was predictable, or that a different choice would certainly have worked better.
The useful response is to check the assumptions behind the decision. Was I assuming that a memorable title would also be easy to find? Was I assuming that people would already know the name? Those are questions I can investigate without declaring the entire project a mistake.
What I changed when naming the book
I agonized quite a bit about the title of The Mistakes That Make Us. I worried about repeating the naming problem by calling the book My Favorite Mistake. A book with many people’s stories also needed a title that went beyond “my.”
I surveyed people about possible titles to reduce some of the uncertainty. That did not guarantee the right answer. It gave me more information for a prediction: which title would represent the book’s content and help an interested reader recognize its value?
Questions to ask before choosing a name
What does someone expect from the name alone? Ask potential readers or listeners to describe what they think it means before explaining your intent. Their answer can reveal a gap you would otherwise miss.
What else uses the same words? Look in the places where your audience would search. Consider whether a useful description or subtitle would clarify the subject.
What would make a change worthwhile? A new name can create confusion for people who already know the old one. Define the problem you want to solve and look for evidence before assuming a complete rename is the answer.
For me, the lesson is to learn from the decision without pretending I could have known everything in advance. The same approach applies well beyond naming a podcast. If you want to hear what that learning looks like in other settings, these podcast discussion questions offer a place to start.
Bring a useful conversation to your team
Start with a free preview of The Mistakes That Make Us. See how the book approaches learning, accountability, and improvement before deciding whether it is right for you.
Prefer to listen? Choose a My Favorite Mistake episode to discuss with your team. To explore these ideas together, bring Mark to your organization or event.



Hi Mark, I have grown to learn that we all learn from mistakes, and not making any is not going to make you grow. The lessons learned from mistakes may be hard at times, but they can be the most profound lessons that pave a better path of self-discovery and life’s improvisations.
Glad to have discovered you and your article on this topic. Cheers!
Thank you for reading and commenting, Bhruti!