Past business success can make a new venture feel less uncertain than it really is. But knowing how to run one business does not tell us everything we need to know about a different market, product, or customer.
Nir Bashan and Kelly Meyer described that problem in our My Favorite Mistake conversations. Their stories were part of the material I developed for The Mistakes That Make Us that did not make the final book. They offer specific assumptions to examine before putting more resources behind an idea.
Nir Bashan: assuming one success will keep paying off
Creativity expert Nir Bashan is the founder and CEO of The Creator Mindset, and heโs written a book of that title. His clients have included AT&T, Microsoft, Ace Hardware, NFL Network, and JetBlue. Even with his success, Nir believes โit is incredibly important to start talking about the things that didnโt go well for me.โ
As a serial entrepreneur, Nir had a movie production company that produced a cooking documentary, โThe Kitchen,โ that he sold to Universal Studios. His mistake was assuming โeverything will continue on like this forever.โ
They didnโt produce another successful film. They didnโt create additional products or services based on that first hit film, and Nir admits he didnโt listen to his employeesโ ideas. Nir realizes he thought he knew more than everybody else. Instead of moving forward with those ideas, he focused on wringing more profits out of the film instead of testing related ideas that might have brought in more revenue.
โIt worked for a while, and then it tanked.โ It was like โseveral mistakes came together to make one big mistake.โ
The production company went out of business. Nir let everybody go.
โYou want to just crawl into a hole somewhere and die after you make these types of mistakes.โ
To his credit, Nir learned from his mistakes that โif you’re not continually innovating, continually creating โ and changing and adapting and introducing new things โ and testing, and then seeing if things work or not and adjusting, then you’re forever relegated into the dustbin of history.โ
Nir now works to help companies avoid repeating his mistake, as โthe difference between a great business and an average business is how adaptable and receptive you are to change.โ
โBeing a serial entrepreneur and having lots of businesses, I think it’s good to have the things come up because that’s how you learn.โ
Nir tries to help people view mistakes in a positive way, when โmost people view [mistakes] with negativity.โ He has worked hard to shift his own โgut instinctโ about mistakes away from getting โupset or hurt or sadโ โ because the negativity hampers our ability to improve.
When you can, instead, say, โthis happened for a reason, then you open up the potential of possibility,โ which allows you to solve problems creatively.
โIf you make a mistake and you look at the mistake in a positive way, it will open up. I promise you avenues of solutions that were never there before.โ
Kelly Meyer: assuming success will transfer to a new industry
Kelly Meyer is the author of the book How Not to Start a Damn Brewery. The book is based on his experience โ and his mistakes. His โone big seminal mistakeโ was โliterally just opening a brewery the wrong time.โ Because of the proliferation of Texas craft breweries, Kelly thinks the timing would have been much better five years earlier.
His second mistake was not avoiding the ten mistakes that he shares in the ten chapters of the book, mistakes he thinks are โpretty universal.โ
Kelly started his brewery as a โfun semi-retirement thingโ in 2011 after selling his successful company of eight fitness centers, selling at the top of the market. The millions he made led to โarroganceโ and his belief that a brewery โjust couldnโt be that hard,โ, especially looking โat all the idiots in the industry.โ Kelly also admits that he didnโt approach this as responsibly (he invested over $750,000 without having a business plan) or as maturely as he could (case in point, the โidiotsโ comment).
One mistake was brewing a range of German-style beers in a market that was crowded with that style, and consumers already had their favorites. He adjusted by going โnicheโ to produce esoteric beers that required a lot of consumer education about these โhigher price, more artisticโ products. He learned that the best beer wouldnโt automatically win in the marketplace because marketing and distribution matter greatly.
His wife quit in 2019, and Kelly started writing the book and then hit record sales during the Covid shutdown. But none of the โlittle runs were sustainable.โ Kelly shut down the brewery in the spring of 2021.
โPain is weakness leaving the body… if it doesn’t kill you, it makes you stronger. When I wrote that book, one of the things that I realized was that I wasn’t still making these mistakes. So, clearly, the business was stronger in 2021 than it was in 2011. It just still wasn’t strong enough.โ
โSo learn from my mistakes,โ Kelly says, and he has started his own podcast where he interviews and learns from owners of other failed breweries.
Would he ever be tempted to repeat this mistake of starting a brewery? No. โI would be a single man if I did, and I love my wife tremendously.โ
“It is possible to commit no mistakes and still lose. That is not weakness, that is life.” – Captain Jean-Luc Picard, U.S.S. Enterprise
What these business mistakes can teach us
Neither story proves that failure inevitably produces success. Kellyโs business improved and still closed. Nirโs willingness to learn did not undo the loss of the production company. I think that distinction matters: learning is useful even when it cannot rescue the original venture.
The practical question is what we can learn before the stakes get larger. A good product, an earlier success, or enthusiasm for an industry is a starting point. Each leaves assumptions about customers, costs, distribution, and the work needed to deliver.
Check the next venture on its own terms
What has changed? Name the differences between the earlier success and the new situation. A customer, market, or operating model that looks familiar may behave differently.
What are people trying to tell us? Nirโs account includes ideas he did not listen to. Ask whose observations you might be dismissing, especially when they challenge a result you want to believe.
What can we test before committing more? Identify the assumption most likely to undermine the plan. Decide what evidence would support it, what would challenge it, and how to learn within limits you can afford.
For a more detailed approach, read how to check assumptions before they become mistakes. And when an experiment disappoints, the way leaders respond shapes whether people share what they learned.
Bring a useful conversation to your team
Start with a free preview of The Mistakes That Make Us. See how the book approaches learning, accountability, and improvement before deciding whether it is right for you.
Prefer to listen? Choose a My Favorite Mistake episode to discuss with your team. To explore these ideas together, bring Mark to your organization or event.


